All Gas, No Brakes, with Ryan Page | Transcript
Marketing x Analytics · Season 5, Episode 5 · November 10, 2026
Alex Sofronas talks with Ryan Page, founder and CEO of Backpocket CPA, about finance, marketing measurement, and agency economics.
Listen on Apple Podcasts · Watch on YouTube · Download the original captions (SRT)
This transcript uses the show’s published captions. Select a timestamp to jump to that point in the video. Chapter headings follow the published show notes; caption timing is preserved.
Chapters
- 00:00 Cold open: two questions from this episode
- 00:27 Welcome: Ryan Page of Backpocket CPA
- 01:08 How Ryan got into accounting
- 01:53 How a CPA looks at marketing spend
- 03:11 What executives cut when money gets tight
- 05:50 Why Ryan works with creative agencies
- 06:59 Fixing agency cash flow
- 09:26 Utilization and client profitability
- 12:17 Price elasticity and gas and brakes
- 14:05 Why marketing has to move toward finance
- 18:33 Incrementality testing
- 20:20 Bots, privacy and the attribution gap
- 22:32 What finance cares about most: profit margin
- 24:33 Mining sales transcripts and CRM data
- 27:01 Margin by product and service line
- 30:08 Step one for launching ads
- 33:10 Why you should start with direct mail
- 36:42 The CPA breakup kit
- 38:23 Clustering your ICP
- 42:42 Reaching your ICP through creators
- 46:08 Champion vs. challenger testing
- 49:39 AI-made ads and Meta's AI creative
- 53:36 Marketing is all bets
- 54:54 Matching creative to the channel
- 56:47 Agency benchmarks: the 50/30 rule
- 57:56 Volume, margin and concentration risk
- 59:55 Top-heavy agency teams
- 63:59 Outsourcing and offshore leaders
- 66:40 Wrap-up
Cold open: two questions from this episode
00:00 Alex Sofronas: outside of marketing, like, what, what is finance optimizing toward?
00:04 Ryan Page: Profit margin.
00:06 Alex Sofronas: Really?
00:07 Ryan Page: I think profit margin is, like, the most overlooked metric,
00:13 Alex Sofronas: What are the things that separate the successful from the unsuccessful agencies from a financial perspective?
00:19 Ryan Page: the key metrics there are 50/30.
Welcome: Ryan Page of Backpocket CPA
00:27 Alex Sofronas: Hello and welcome to the Marketing x Analytics Podcast. I'm your host, Alex Sofronas, and today we're on with Ryan Page. Ryan, would you like to introduce yourself?
00:36 Ryan Page: I'm Ryan Page, founder and CEO of Backpocket CPA, and the boring thing we do is, uh, bookkeeping, but what makes us fun and unique is that we work primarily with, women-led creative agencies, and we help them solve their financial intimidation.
00:53 Alex Sofronas: I like that. That's, that's a great mission.
00:56 Ryan Page: It's, uh, it's fun, and I'd say it's been a, an evolution getting to the point where I feel very clear on, what we do, but it- yeah, it, it is fun.
How Ryan got into accounting
01:09 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. So how did you get started?
01:12 Ryan Page: fell into accounting, I- I would say. I did it because my dad was a CFO and thought I would, have help when I needed help, and I do leverage him every now and then. but yeah, that was ultimately what got me started, and I stay, because I f- I like the impact that we are able to make. I noticed just through various jobs, I, I've always been in accounting, but noticed through various jobs that, like, when I get into too big of a company, I just feel like I'm a cog in
01:40 Ryan Page: a wheel. And, so yeah, I like helping smaller businesses really just get through all the muck, the things that intimidate them, and, help them make sense of their financials.
How a CPA looks at marketing spend
01:53 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. So how do you Just to jump into it, how do you think about marketing spend? How do you value it?
02:00 Ryan Page: marketing spend as a whole? So I, I kind of think of a P&L or a profit and loss financial statement as a percent of income, pretty much always. So when I think of a marketing agency, percent of income, their, their advertising and marketing line item, I kind of think, like, 10, 15% of, of their revenue should be on marketing spend.
02:26 Alex Sofronas: Just to, uh, uh, so, so you're not looking at returns, you're just looking at proportion to total- I- income?
02:33 Ryan Page: Yeah. We're not, I mean, we're not getting to the full, like, anal- analyst level thing that you would probably do when you're talking ROAS and LTV to CAC. Like, I think we're involved in a lot of that, but I'm not, I'm not super privy to, to that I would say for the most part. and not… We're not super focused on, like, the front end marketing analytics. It's more of, like, how are we, how's the financials looking? How does, like, the overall health of the business,
03:05 Ryan Page: not necessarily just like, you know, that one element of, bringing in new business.
What executives cut when money gets tight
03:11 Alex Sofronas: Right. But you're, so you're on the con- you're on the side of the conversation that the marketers typically don't get to be in. how do executives, like, look at marketing spend when they need to… Like, let's say they're, they need to cut costs.
03:29 Ryan Page: Yeah.
03:29 Alex Sofronas: How, how are they thinking about marketing spend? Are they like, "All right, should we just throw it out?" You know, like, what, what are they thinking?
03:39 Ryan Page: It's funny 'cause it's always a dance. Um, but I think a lot of good leaders are, like, not cutting their marketing spend as one of the first things, just because they know how important that is to, to keep business flowing. I will say though, I do notice a lot people wanna throw money at, like, sales labor, not necessarily marketing, but just sales. It's like, oh, especially founder-led agencies, it's like, "Hey, I just wanna get someone else to
04:07 Ryan Page: be like a BDR or something, do biz dev for us." But, like, it almost never works it seems, at least in the very young, uh, days of running an agency. So yeah.
04:21 Alex Sofronas: Say more about that. What, what do, what do you find, like, that doesn't work about that, and what are the investments that you see that do tend to add direction? Yeah.
04:30 Ryan Page: I, I think that people just want it too soon. Like, if I'm talking about even me, like, I would love to have someone who's always staying top of mind for prospects, doing prospecting, doing sales calls, but, like, my company's too small to be able to support that, and I think a lot of companies are too small to be able to support what, the, uh, that goal. And so, like, you know, they don't have full dialed in product market fit. They don't have, the consistent leads to be able to, like, confidently support that type of
05:04 Ryan Page: person, and I think… Or the processes, that's really a big part of it too, is like, a lot of people wanna be able to say like, "Here you go. Go sell." And it's like, no, you have to have everything, like, pretty dialed in to be able to get people into that, that process.
05:19 Alex Sofronas: Product market fit.
05:21 Ryan Page: Yeah.
05:22 Alex Sofronas: That's a tough thing to get.
05:24 Ryan Page: It is. It's a hunt.
05:26 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Yeah.
05:28 Ryan Page: and espe- I mean, yeah, we're talking founder-led agencies and it's like a lot of people that show up and they go, "Oh, I need this little aspect. Oh, I need like…" Or f- any full service agency, they start as like, "Oh, I like creative." And then the… Someone's like, "Oh, I need a website." And they're like, "Ooh, we can do a website." And then all of a sudden they're full service and it's a different beast.
Why Ryan works with creative agencies
05:50 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, so how, how did you arrive at your specialization?
05:55 Ryan Page: The, the subtle way that I didn't really know was I started an agency back in like 2017 with a friend. did it for a little while with him and then sold, and he kept going on and sold the company again. Um, that was like my first foray into it. but then as I started working with more and more businesses, I just accumulated a few agencies and really liked the business model. really noticed it's a,
06:23 Ryan Page: the, the type of person that needs, the, the help that we do
06:28 Alex Sofronas: You c- you accumulated a few agencies.
06:32 Ryan Page: Well, nah, actually purchased, so poor choice of words on my part. I didn't purchase agencies. I accumulated them as clients, like managing their books.
06:40 Alex Sofronas: Oh, okay. Okay.
06:41 Ryan Page: Yeah. Well, that's- Would've been cool. Yeah. Well- I would love to have a portfolio of them.
06:46 Alex Sofronas: It's like Monopoly. Yeah, no- Yeah. what, what's that process like?
06:48 Ryan Page: managing the books or-
06:50 Alex Sofronas: Yeah or, it- what do you mean? Like, I don't know, like, w- you know, th- this is outside of the typical marketer's scope.
Fixing agency cash flow
06:59 Alex Sofronas: So like-
07:00 Ryan Page: Yeah what d- what does your day-to-day look like? Is it, like s- is it seasonal, I'm assuming? Mm, no. So I mean, a big part of the, the problems that we see, so if I think of a lot of small agencies, they are creative people. They don't like talking to people, to clients about money. They don't like following up on money. They don't like building systems around it. So a lot of the problems that we see are like, there's no
07:29 Ryan Page: invoicing and follow-up system. It's… Or it's like, "Hey, we send an invoice and then we follow up on it in, like two or three months, or we don't follow up on it at all." So that creates the cash flow problem that a lot of smaller a- a- I mean, and even bigger agencies have, is there's no follow-up process. So what I like to do is help them implement something that gets them paid right away. You send the proposal, they enter their bank details, and then that charges monthly no matter what. Like, and then we, we don't have a collection process. Mm-hmm. We
07:58 Ryan Page: know when cash is coming. So that's one of the big things I see. Um, another is around just, like vendor payment process. they're working with a lot of various contractors, depending on, you know, full service, creative agency, yada, yada. and they're very generous with how they pay people. They're just like, "Oh, here you get paid every day." Like, and then all of a sudden the end of the month they have no money and they take like 1,000 bucks for themself or something. So we help them
08:27 Ryan Page: build, um, like AP and vendor payment processes or, one- something I love doing is like, all right, we pay people once a week. We get them to submit their invoice in this way, allocating their time to clients. So then we have start to get to client level profitability, but the vendors themselves are basically giving us the data. So it's like an upstream process that is simplifying the downstream reporting
08:52 Alex Sofronas: Nice which, yeah, that probably, you probably like that being an analyst, huh? Yeah. The ana- the analytics people love you for that. 'Cause a lot of the time it is structural, you know? Yeah. And, and so that is the way that people should be thinking about it. Like, that's You know, I, not that I had that opinion before you said it, like, but I, I see that as, really, like, a good thing to focus on-
09:21 Ryan Page: Yeah
09:21 Alex Sofronas: is how do we structure the business in a way that makes it easier for us to make decisions?
Utilization and client profitability
09:27 Ryan Page: Yeah. And they're not, like, thinking about that, right? They're thinking about getting new projects and servicing clients, and like, so when it comes to the admin stuff, it's just always back burner. Yeah. And yeah, like, when agencies get bigger too, then it starts to shift into, like, utilization. We have five employees, 10 employees, like, how do we make sure that we're giving them the right amount of work and balancing their satisfaction? So then it gets into, like, managing time per project and, utilization
09:58 Ryan Page: and that type of stuff too to ensure optimum profitability.
10:01 Alex Sofronas: How do you do that? Like, uh, you know, out- outside of, like, the, you know, looking at time spent, like, working, I guess, like, how do you determine if people are overworked?
10:15 Ryan Page: there's industry benchmarks, I would say. So time spent working is, is one of the big pieces of it, because that's driving the benchmark, I would say, but you figure 70 to 80% utilization, or 70% of their time is considered billable, then that's like That, that's should be what it is. and then the flip side of that is just the, like, qualitative metrics. How's the team feeling? Are they overworked? are they
10:46 Ryan Page: spread across too many clients? so there is an aspect of it that's not just purely numbers driven, but I'd say it's balancing the two.
10:55 Alex Sofronas: And what's your role in those kinds of discussions?
10:59 Ryan Page: I- it's mostly around, I would say, structuring the, like, the reporting on that. and then just I, I s- present it. "Okay, this is, here's our list of clients. Here's the time that we're spending on clients. Like, how does this align to the deliverable? is this what's expected? How should we move forward from here?" and so I'm kind of just in the room, like, presenting it and just making sure that we get to, like, a resolution around expectation and then where does this go?
11:29 Alex Sofronas: Yeah.
11:30 Ryan Page: where does this go next?
11:31 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, I mean, that's, that's analytics. You, you're, uh, you're on the finance side, but it's the same thing. It's, it's just a different, uh, you know, dialect perhaps.
11:42 Ryan Page: Yeah. It's, I mean, it's almost sitting in between the finance and ops a bit. It's kind of trying to tie the two, together. Uh, and then obviously, I mean, where when you get to margin level and client level profitability conversations, it's like, what options do you have? You have increase the price or reduce the cost. And so when we talk about reducing the cost, we're talking about reducing hours on projects, or then we get pulled in with the increasing the price. So like, what does it mean for us to increase the
12:11 Ryan Page: price? What packages are we offering? So then it kind of just loops back to the beginning on the sales piece a bit.
Price elasticity and gas and brakes
12:18 Alex Sofronas: Do you do elasticity tests at all?
12:21 Ryan Page: No. Tell, what, tell me more about that. I don't know much about that.
12:24 Alex Sofronas: I was hoping you would tell me. It's, it's, you know, it's, I know they do it in CPG.
12:29 Ryan Page: Mm you know, it's basically looking at the relationship between price and demand- Mm 2: and seeing how much price can be incr- like, what, what's the factor that we're- Yeah that the business will lose, um- Uh increasing the price and trying to find an optimal level. I don't do that.
12:49 Alex Sofronas: We do the opposite in marketing. I do- We're like, how much- Yeah money can we give them for an offer-
12:53 Ryan Page: Yeah stay profitable? Where, where, yeah. So and then it's like, all right, how much can we increase this before we get a no? Yeah.
13:03 Alex Sofronas: That's
13:03 Ryan Page: the reality of it, but-
13:05 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's, And I think that's by design, you know, there needs to be gas and brakes.
13:11 Ryan Page: Yeah.
13:11 Alex Sofronas: That'll be this episode's title.
13:15 Ryan Page: All gas, no brakes.
13:19 Alex Sofronas: yeah. It's, uh, it's interesting. Finance is in a totally different realm, but doing the same thing. It's like a, I think it's a good hedge, you know. Yeah. Like, an executive would want two sides to the spend story. Like-
13:37 Ryan Page: Yeah you know? It's, it's how I mean Yeah. What, what do you think about the marketing data that's coming Because in? I'm sure, I'm sure people, you know, pitch you on like, well, you know, this is why this should have more cost or whatever, you know, or why we should have more spend. But like, what, what matters to you when you hear about, like, marketing success? I don't know that I know what you mean.
Why marketing has to move toward finance
14:06 Alex Sofronas: Well, like, let's- and maybe you're not, uh, maybe you're not the person, like, that they're saying this to. Maybe it's the executive, like- Yeah the, that you're working with. but, like, you know, marketing operates with a totally different set of metrics, and I think one of the things that will define marketing analytics in the next decade-
14:26 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm is alignment with finance. Totally. I think it's one of the biggest pro- like, hardest things to solve.
14:34 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. No, and it's because it requires marketing to move in the finance direction, not the other way around.
14:41 Ryan Page: Really?
14:42 Alex Sofronas: oh, yeah. Yeah. Uh, no question. Because, like, in reality it is a lack of information on the marketing side. Like, the finance side is very rational. Like, it's based in data. Yeah. And if marketing can't provide that data-
15:00 Ryan Page: Yeah
15:01 Alex Sofronas: it's not irrational to question it.
15:05 Ryan Page: But would you say, couldn't you say that, like, I should be meeting you halfway? Like, I have the data in a structured way now to be able to come to you and say, like, "Okay, does this make sense to you, marketing team?" And then, like, how do we, how do we marry this up a bit more?
15:22 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. I, I don't think anything's wrong on your side. I don't think anything's wrong on either side. I, Yeah. I think the measuring capabilities have been subpar because of technology. You know, like, and I think that with AI and all this, like, just we have a lot more tools now. It's, it's incumbent on marketing to come to the table with more- Finance primed data. Like, like think about the move to s- chief revenue officers.
15:54 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Like, the, those were not a huge thing like 10, 15 years ago.
16:00 Ryan Page: Yeah.
16:01 Alex Sofronas: Now they're, like, pretty common and- Mm-hmm and often leading marketing. Hmm. Right? In s- in lieu of a CMO. Yeah. And it makes perfect sense to me.
16:10 Ryan Page: Yeah.
16:12 Alex Sofronas: Because marketing should not… No, no marketer wants to be a cost center. They all- Mm want to show. Like they're, they're tr- it's like, you know, it, it, the baby wants to speak, but it's like it can't. It's, it's just tr- it's really trying. Yeah. So marketing is really trying to show that it has value, and it just hasn't had the words.
16:35 Ryan Page: Hmm.
16:36 Alex Sofronas: Um, and, now it's becoming a lot easier. I, I think, but also there needs to be a bit of a, a cultural shift, towards better testing and, and, and towards, like, offer-based marketing and, and, like, mo- maybe, maybe more, more rigidness when it comes to attribution. 'Cause it's like UTMs are still the freaking Wild West. Like- Yeah you just put whatever, you
17:06 Alex Sofronas: know? There's very, very rarely, if ever, any standardization across the years. Mm. People come and go.
17:13 Ryan Page: Yeah.
17:14 Alex Sofronas: And then those new people have new opinions about how UT- you know, it's like-
17:17 Ryan Page: Yeah that makes it really hard to show consistent value. Versus, like, finance- Mm-hmm 50 years ago had the same words as today. Yeah. It's true.
17:28 Alex Sofronas: That's a big… Yeah, so that's why marketing has to move in that direction. 'Cause Yeah. that's the one that hasn't needed to change.
17:35 Ryan Page: Hmm. I mean, but also finance hasn't changed. Like, maybe, I don't know. That's- Yeah. It could that is interesting. You guys, I mean, you guys are just… Like, the marketing industry as a whole is iterating so fast, um- Yeah all the time, it seems, and we're just kinda, like, the slow and steady, like, "Ah, we're not doing that."
17:57 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. But, uh- The brakes it's interest- yeah. The, there it is. Gas and brakes. Yeah. That's funny. Yeah.
18:04 Ryan Page: Um, hmm. I think when you talk about like, I think you mentioned like attribution, right?
18:11 Alex Sofronas: Mm-hmm.
18:12 Ryan Page: It… That's such a hard thing to pin down 'cause like you fill a funnel today, like someone converts years down the road, like where's it gonna be attributed? So it's just like a, it gets fuzzy qui- I forget the term that I heard for it, but I, yeah, I can't remember. But yeah, it's, it's, very interesting.
Incrementality testing
18:33 Alex Sofronas: Yeah.
18:33 Ryan Page: What, what other like- marketing analytics do you, do you have up your sleeve or, like, look at frequently or anything?
18:42 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. I mean, I think that incrementality testing is worth its weight in gold- Mm-hmm and should be the foundation of l- a lot more than it is in ter- 'cause it can be extrapolated for a lot of things. it's basically a provable return on investment. Like, I could say to you, "If you give me this much money, I will cause this many additional sales." Yeah. And
19:12 Alex Sofronas: you can actually, like, scientifically say that. Sure. And you can test the degradation of that curve- Yeah of that lift curve as you change certain variables, like volume or the, you know, quantity or, intensity- Mm of the offer. Yeah you know, $100 versus $200. Mm and there's some really interesting patterns. And i- like, the most successful marketers I've seen are the ones that are moving
19:42 Alex Sofronas: towards that financial framework- Mm because that's who's holding the purse.
19:47 Ryan Page: Yeah.
19:48 Alex Sofronas: You, you talk the language of the person holding the purse. You don't tell them, like, "No, you gotta learn my language. Like, listen-"
19:55 Ryan Page: Yeah Impressions. Okay? Let me tell you about impressions." It's like they don't care about impressions. Yeah.
20:00 Alex Sofronas: They shouldn't care about impressions, frankly, because that's a, that's a very hand-wavy signal and, uh, you know, that, that's- It's like followers. What's that?
20:11 Ryan Page: I said it's like followers.
20:13 Alex Sofronas: Exactly.
20:14 Ryan Page: But, but lower.
20:16 Alex Sofronas: Right. Way lower. It, it's views.
20:19 Ryan Page: Yeah.
Bots, privacy and the attribution gap
20:21 Alex Sofronas: Um, not even comments. Yeah. And, I, I was just talking about this earlier today. It, I think we're in an interesting place when it comes to bots because for the longest time, like, for, for since we've been saying bots-
20:34 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm
20:34 Alex Sofronas: that has been a bad thing.
20:37 Ryan Page: Yeah.
20:38 Alex Sofronas: Now you have bots. I have bots. Everybody listening to this podcast has bots.
20:44 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm.
20:45 Alex Sofronas: And those bots are operating on our behalf w- on our intent, and they are, like, searching for, you know, companies or w- whenever, whenever they're on s- a company's site, that is to help solve a problem of ours. So it is a good thing if- Yeah our bot goes to a company's website.
21:07 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm.
21:07 Alex Sofronas: You, so you wouldn't want to discount a bot. You
21:12 Ryan Page: Yeah.
21:12 Alex Sofronas: would want to acknowledge that that's a gap in attribution. Like- That's my bot, but it doesn't say it's my bot.
21:20 Ryan Page: Hmm.
21:22 Alex Sofronas: Um, no, it doesn't even say it's me half the time 'cause Apple's like, "We know."
21:27 Ryan Page: Yeah. Nobody else can know." You can't know that.
21:31 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. So it's, uh, it's interesting how the, the privacy and, like, bot landscape is changing. Hmm. Speaking about impressions, like that's It's such a changing ecosystem.
21:47 Ryan Page: Yeah.
21:48 Alex Sofronas: It's ha- skip it, right? Like, we need to go all the way down the line to how much profit, how much additional profit can we get for every dollar- Mm-hmm and up to what limit, you know? And Yeah. if you just put it in simple financial terms- Mm-hmm that's how marketers are successful with, with gaining budget, with whatever it's… I mean, the goal isn't gaining budget, right? It's, it's getting more sales.
22:15 Ryan Page: Hmm.
22:16 Alex Sofronas: it's lowering the cost of conversions.
22:21 Ryan Page: Yeah.
22:21 Alex Sofronas: That's what marketers and finance people want.
22:24 Ryan Page: Yeah. Hmm. It's very interesting.
22:27 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. What… I mean, is it? Is it what you want? Like,
What finance cares about most: profit margin
22:32 Alex Sofronas: what, what-
22:32 Ryan Page: I-
22:33 Alex Sofronas: What does the finance team want broadly speaking? Like, I know for me, like, I'm successful if I can lower the cost to acquire customers, and if I can be trusted with a budget and do so well that I get more budget.
22:50 Ryan Page: I think the size of the company is gonna be the driver of that. Like, I think those goals are amazing goals, but if I'm thinking of, like, a $2 million founder-led company, like, they're maybe not even to that level of sophistication yet of knowing that. Like, it's probably built mostly on referrals, honestly. may- I mean, we're talking marketing agencies- Right, right, right, right so maybe they're running some of this stuff, like a more
23:19 Ryan Page: sophisticated owner than an accounting firm, but-
23:23 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, but outside of marketing, like, what, what is finance optimizing toward? Is it-
23:29 Ryan Page: Profit margin.
23:30 Alex Sofronas: Really?
23:31 Ryan Page: I think. I, I mean, that's my opinion. I think profit margin is, like, the most overlooked metric, everywhere 'cause I think it, it ensures, like, it ensures profitability. You look at your, your g- delivery margin or your gross margin, like if that is off, then the rest of the business is off.
23:55 Alex Sofronas: Right. I did not expect that, which I think is so awesome.
23:59 Ryan Page: What did you expect?
24:01 Alex Sofronas: Compliance. Like you don't- Ah wanna get the company in trouble.
24:06 Ryan Page: I mean, obviously we don't want that. but like that's not what I… I'm here to run a business. I'm not here to-
24:13 Alex Sofronas: Right uh, like that's what a tax person's for. I'm not a tax person. Yeah. You wanna, you wanna hang your hat- on something that, that matters.
24:20 Ryan Page: Yeah. I think what really, I mean, it's like we said earlier, it's the blend of finance and ops. That part is really interesting and like yeah, th- that's probably why I care more about margin than like did we file in X states?
Mining sales transcripts and CRM data
24:34 Alex Sofronas: Right. That's so interesting 'cause like I think at the height of, at marketing analytics, it's very similar. Very d- like I would say there's very slight differences in the type of data that we're looking at.
24:49 Ryan Page: Yeah.
24:50 Alex Sofronas: Like I would look at- More of the sales side. Like, I would lo- I, I love transcripts. I don't get to use them enough.
24:59 Ryan Page: Hmm.
25:00 Alex Sofronas: I love thinking about, like, what patterns can we pick up in the sales motion, and how can we advise, like, for more efficient funnel conversion?
25:14 Ryan Page: So you're listening to transcripts or extracting transcripts and-
25:18 Alex Sofronas: I, whenever I can, yeah, I g- I-
25:19 Ryan Page: Wow pump them into bots and… I, I mean, I'll even use that for myself just to, like- Yeah get oriented with what's going on with a particular client. Mm-hmm.
25:29 Alex Sofronas: And that's just, that's one example, and I don't get to do it enough. But-
25:34 Ryan Page: Yeah there's plenty of others. Like, just analyzing the sales and CRM data. What is the composition of this account? And I've created a recommendation model for that in the past- Mm-hmm on who should be added to a buying persona group- Yeah um, based on successful patterns. Hmm.
25:53 Alex Sofronas: What has led to increase… uh, let's say it's, so you're working with agencies, right? And those agencies sell services, and if- they probably sell a few. And so you can look at the pattern of what is the most successful, starter service. Yeah. And then for, let's say they start on a different service, what's the next one that, that is- Mm you know, the most, uh, successful- Yeah in, in client spend. Or-
26:22 Ryan Page: Hmm or in profit, right? Yeah.
26:26 Alex Sofronas: which might be different than just spend. Yeah. Uh, and I wouldn't look at that. I would look at overall spend. I'd be like, "This is how we get them to spend more."
26:33 Ryan Page: Hmm.
26:35 Alex Sofronas: And then you, you'd be, you'd be like, "Hmm.
26:38 Ryan Page: Hmm." Hmm. Well, I think you just would take the spend and times the margin to-
26:45 Alex Sofronas: That's the thing, it's always a general margin for- Yeah for me at least. I've never been privy, or at least the companies I've been at, like it's not generally shared the product specific margin. Yeah. Maybe people don't care in marketing as much.
Margin by product and service line
27:01 Ryan Page: Maybe that's the gap of the finance and marketing. Like- You think- I think it comes down to structure- Okay of the data a lot too, like it, finance data. I think a lot of companies, I don't know what size companies you're, you've, you've been in or seen, but I think a lot of them are- All of them. All of them. Like, yeah. So a lot of, I would say smaller ones, even bigger ones, they get so big that they don't, they like, "We have 100,000 products."
27:30 Ryan Page: Like how do you know the margin per product kind of thing. Then you come up a level to like, what's above product?
27:38 Alex Sofronas: Is
27:38 Ryan Page: it- Class or something like, I don't know.
27:40 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, yeah, yeah. A line.
27:41 Ryan Page: Margin per class. Yeah. Product line. And yeah, product line. Thank you. but yeah, I think like I've, I love structuring the financials as like departments and then you have, like you have it that way too, product lines if there's products. Part of the reason I like agencies too is 'cause there's not really products. Service lines, I guess.
28:00 Alex Sofronas: Mm-hmm so we're looking at service lines, we're looking at departments, and just like having s- data structured in that way to be able to get to margin by whatever slice and dice you wanna get. What's the next step when you… I mean, you're also looking at the lowest margin. Or yeah. Right.
28:18 Ryan Page: Yeah. Lowest margins are the first address, first ones. and it, maybe that's again the gap is like I'm looking at the lowest margin and saying, "How do we get this to our 50, 60% margin target?" Uh, and that's either the cutting the labor or getting them up a tier or changing pricing. Mm-hmm. But then the, the gap is like, all right, highest margins, how do we crank on this more? That's like maybe not a way that we take it. How do we
28:48 Ryan Page: crank on this and then go to someone like you to be able to lean in and do whatever you're talking about, incremental testing or-
28:56 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. No, it- oh, and yeah, that's interesting. Right. So first of all, we do a similar practice. It, it sounds similar, but I think it's actually different. So we look at underperformers and overperformers, but you can, you can call campaigns that-
29:18 Ryan Page: Yeah in a bun- like from different perspectives. Hmm.
29:22 Alex Sofronas: And the way that you're judged determines like the framework. Like, and, and often they are actually opposed. So you h- you have to… Like, once you're… You know, marketing is very much like a game. Like you, you make, you know… Like I know if I make these choices, I'll- Yeah I will have this outcome. And if I make these other choices, I'll have that outcome. Hmm. And I also know the other effects that they will cause. And so depending on the scoring system,
29:53 Alex Sofronas: it dictates how- Sure like what you do. Like it's, human behavior is, it, at a large enough scale, absolutely predictable. You like-
30:03 Ryan Page: Hmm.
30:03 Alex Sofronas: The, that's- That's
30:04 Ryan Page: fascinating.
30:05 Alex Sofronas: Well, it, that's w- we're, that's what marketing does. Yeah.
30:07 Ryan Page: It, it is.
Step one for launching ads
30:08 Alex Sofronas: Yeah.
30:09 Ryan Page: So let, let me ask you this. How would you take your, like, expertise and skillset and like break it down to like step one? Say someone is like, they have product market fit, and now they wanna like launch ads or something or start some campaign. Like how would you even do that? Or-
30:31 Alex Sofronas: Hmm. That's a great question. So you need to know who you're selling to, and then you need to- and then you think about, like, who, uh, wh- where do they spend their time?
30:44 Ryan Page: Yeah.
30:45 Alex Sofronas: Like, if it's, if it's, like generally older folks-
30:48 Ryan Page: Yeah
30:50 Alex Sofronas: then you sh- probably shouldn't be running meta ads or, or, uh, maybe, uh, what's a better example? Like Spotify ads. Yeah. The domains Spotify ads. But, but like if they are, uh, you know, young gen whatever is, whatever we're on at this point, gen, um- I don't
31:06 Ryan Page: know, A,
31:06 Alex Sofronas: B? I, and I was, I, it's beta? I don't know. then you'd probably wanna do TikTok ads and- Mm the cr- creator, ads. That's very hot right now is creator ads.
31:19 Ryan Page: Hmm.
31:20 Alex Sofronas: Um, if it's boomers, I would do AI slop on Facebook for days. I would just have- Yeah bots posting Do they
31:27 Ryan Page: love that?
31:27 Alex Sofronas: Oh.
31:28 Ryan Page: Are they the ones that love that?
31:30 Alex Sofronas: I, I think they're the ones that fall for it. No offense, guys.
31:34 Ryan Page: Do, do you-
31:34 Alex Sofronas: They fall for it.
31:35 Ryan Page: Do you run meta ads?
31:38 Alex Sofronas: no. But I don't, I don't really run ads. When I do run ads, it's either LinkedIn, 'cause that's where my audience is.
31:45 Ryan Page: Huh.
31:46 Alex Sofronas: and I'll do… Like that's where I post my, podcasts. So Huh. I'll boost like an episode to get more- Oh, yeah.
31:52 Ryan Page: Huh um, or I'll do, what I have like some little CPG stuff every, every so often, and I will do meta- Hmm
32:03 Alex Sofronas: and Google- Yeah Ad- AdWords and, or GA4, I don't know what they're calling it.
32:09 Ryan Page: Huh. Huh and then good old-fashioned direct mail. I love- Really? Like, but I'll do it myself. Like I'll, like I, I, I'm a crafty person. I'll- Yeah I'll do it myself. So like- For, for what? you know, a good amount of people. What's that? What are you, what are you sending direct mail, or what are you promoting?
32:30 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Well, so- Just CPG? Yeah. Yeah. So Oh. like my family will import like a couple of like, it's not a real drum, it's like a metal box- Hmm but like of olive oil from Greece, and then I'll like- Wow print out a flyer. I've, I did this, uh, like a year and a half ago.
32:50 Ryan Page: Yeah?
32:50 Alex Sofronas: And, uh- It's like
32:51 Ryan Page: garage sale flyer?
32:53 Alex Sofronas: Even better. I'm just kidding. No, it drove to the website, right? So it had a… So I did a meta ad, and I printed, and then I- Yeah I literally bought a list, 'cause like you can buy, that's the best thing about direct mail. Huh. In fact, I, I haven't, this is a fa- this is a great exercise, by the way.
Why you should start with direct mail
33:11 Ryan Page: Yeah.
33:11 Alex Sofronas: I've never been asked this before. you should start with direct mail, and the reason why is legal.
33:18 Ryan Page: Legal?
33:19 Alex Sofronas: Legal. Because you can get data in the direct mail space that no other tactic would- That's so funny dream of. Huh. You can buy, like, I could buy data about you. Yeah. And not just, like- Your demographics. Like-
33:36 Ryan Page: Yeah like a th- like probably 5,000 different data points about you. Wow.
33:44 Alex Sofronas: Most of them are modeled based off of other data points about you. Huh. So it's like slop kind of.
33:50 Ryan Page: Yeah.
33:50 Alex Sofronas: But again, like, because- I see it's large numbers-
33:54 Ryan Page: Yeah it gets it right enough- Huh that it becomes economical. Wow.
34:00 Alex Sofronas: So what you- I'll have to look
34:01 Ryan Page: into that.
34:02 Alex Sofronas: So, so here's where it gets good. So you, you buy 10,000 people- Yeah 10,000 people's data.
34:09 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm.
34:11 Alex Sofronas: And you buy a good amount of signals about them, or maybe you have unlimited. I don't know, depends on-
34:16 Ryan Page: Yeah who you're going with. Tiki is a good brand. I'm- Hm a huge fan of Tiki. Invested in them early on. Tiki for, buying data?
34:25 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, Tiki. Huh. Yeah. Uh, great, yeah. Or now they've rebranded to Watt, Watt Data. Like, uh-
34:31 Ryan Page: Like watts?
34:32 Alex Sofronas: Energy
34:33 Ryan Page: W-A-
34:33 Alex Sofronas: Yeah W-A-T-T? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Watt. Huh. so you buy the data, then you own, you own it. What you can do is upload it to- Yeah Facebook, and you can say, "Facebook, give me a lookalike campaign." I know you can't- Oh, wow tell me who you targeted because, you know, Facebook lobbied for the privacy restrictions.
34:55 Ryan Page: Huh.
34:55 Alex Sofronas: Because it's good for them.
34:57 Ryan Page: Yeah.
34:57 Alex Sofronas: Because it means they get to keep all the carts. Uh, they- Hm they don't have to tell you… You know, they, they tell you how they did on the test.
35:05 Ryan Page: Yeah.
35:06 Alex Sofronas: You don't even get to see it, you know? Huh. And that's not how direct mail works at all. I mean, sure, if you work with an agency and they, their proprietary modeling is the reason why you're getting your results- Yeah they're, they're probably not gonna tell you exactly everybody who they mailed, but they almost f- every single, pretty much every single time will tell you, "Here are the people that purchased, um, that we mailed." Interesting. And that, Facebook won't do that.
35:34 Ryan Page: Yeah.
35:34 Alex Sofronas: They, they won't tell you everybody who purchased, who saw their ad. I mean, maybe, maybe, but a lot of that identity resolution stuff is not, not good. And like, especially, like Apple is just on a campaign to, like, just mess all the chips up on the table. Huh. You know? Like, they'll change your IP address all the time, and they're just- Huh they're just messing with everybody.
35:57 Ryan Page: Yeah.
35:58 Alex Sofronas: Um, which, like, seems, seems like it's good, but it's, it's not. Huh. It's not helping anybody 'cause they're keeping all the data.
36:06 Ryan Page: Yeah.
36:06 Alex Sofronas: and, and just using it however they want. Totally.
36:09 Ryan Page: Yeah.
36:10 Alex Sofronas: All these companies are getting in trouble all the time-
36:12 Ryan Page: Yeah for, for using data the way they want. Interesting they, they don't have to do much about it because it's like- Yeah only Denmark is finding them, and it's only, like, 1% of their revenue, so Hmm.
36:26 Alex Sofronas: Who cares?
36:26 Ryan Page: Wow.
36:26 Alex Sofronas: You know?
36:28 Ryan Page: Direct mail. Never would've guessed that. Yeah, start, start there- But I guess it's the data play and then- 'cause
36:31 Alex Sofronas: of the data yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and you don't even have to technically send out the direct mail. You, you- but the list is what matters. Yeah. Like, buy the pe- Yeah buy the people's data.
The CPA breakup kit
36:42 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm. You know what I thought would be, like, a good, uh, or a fun direct mail thing for us would be, like, a, a CPA breakup kit, and, like, you basically, you're sending to a bunch of people, like, things that, like, old CPAs have. Like, I don't know, some pen and paper or, like, a cassette tape or something. Hmm. And then it's like, "When you're ready to come to the 21st century," like love it I "here's Backpocket CPA."
37:10 Alex Sofronas: I love it. Yes. Yes.
37:13 Ryan Page: Yeah.
37:14 Alex Sofronas: Um-
37:14 Ryan Page: I'll send you one.
37:16 Alex Sofronas: You should. Yeah. You should. See what I mean I can help you with it. I can help you with it. Um-
37:21 Ryan Page: Perfect there's, there's so many tricks in- Hmm the direct mail space that you would never believe. Like, do you wanna hear- Huh a good one? Yeah.
37:31 Alex Sofronas: You, you, you know it, but you've never th- thought, you thought it. That's how I reacted. companies will intentionally send Letters that look like official government, notices.
37:44 Ryan Page: Yeah.
37:45 Alex Sofronas: Because you will think it is a government notice and open it.
37:48 Ryan Page: I've definitely noticed that, except I rip them. I go- "This looks fake."
37:55 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, no, uh, you get, you get good at telling- Yeah you're like, no way. 'Cause the government- Yeah never like…
38:00 Ryan Page: Yeah.
38:00 Alex Sofronas: You know, how, how often is the government asking me, to do something? Yeah. So, you know, you- Only
38:05 Ryan Page: IRS letters.
38:07 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
38:09 Ryan Page: Dang.
38:09 Alex Sofronas: So-
38:09 Ryan Page: Huh that's one. And like- Yeah you know, for, there's all sorts of optimizations by audience, too. So- Yeah now that we have AI, we can all pretend to be, like, world-class data scientists. Yeah.
Clustering your ICP
38:24 Alex Sofronas: And myself included. And so I love clustering models. Dividing your ICP into- Yeah behaviorally distinct groups. And this- Yeah is where the data you purchase becomes really relevant. Maybe, maybe direct mail wasn't the right way to put it. Just buying the data. Yeah. Like, like who, who are you, you know, who's, who's your ICP? Like, you need to s- you need to know who that is. Like who do
38:52 Alex Sofronas: you want? Yeah. Okay. And then you break it up, and you're like, all right, these are the distinct groups that are behaviorally different. Huh. That's the key. Like, they-
39:03 Ryan Page: Behaviorally different.
39:04 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Like when it- So- Oh, yeah. Go ahead.
39:07 Ryan Page: I was gonna say, so how, like how many things do you put in a different cluster? How many attributes create a cluster?
39:15 Alex Sofronas: There is a s- like a cutoff point. There's a science to it. Four or five. Um, yeah. It's us- Four. Yeah. It's like between four and seven usually. and the model decides that
39:26 Ryan Page: Oh.
39:26 Alex Sofronas: So-
39:26 Ryan Page: You don't even have to decide no. That- You just- There's a whole model around choosing the- Interesting optimal break-off point. 'Cause after certain points, like, it gets too- Yeah yeah. So, so yeah, you, you get your behaviorally distinct clusters, then you just ask the AI to name them so you can- Yeah so you can kinda, you know- Yeah. That's cool Speaker 2: understand it better. And then you t- you start testing. So each of those becomes its own group that you are shepherding towards
39:57 Ryan Page: a purchase. Interesting.
39:59 Alex Sofronas: And you break… So now you've done your ICP, you do the whole thing again at the individual audience level. And the, like, DirecTV is just the easiest example. They are such a simple, like, everybody understands what they sell. And you can understand the s- the different audiences too- Hmm because you have young families, you have-
40:19 Ryan Page: Yeah
40:20 Alex Sofronas: old, old folks who- Yeah are just, like, bored all day.
40:24 Ryan Page: Yeah.
40:24 Alex Sofronas: You have, enterprise customers. You have b- bars, right? Bars are huge customers of TV. Mm-hmm. Uh, and they're a totally separate sales process. Like- Yeah you wouldn't, you wouldn't market to both of them, them and then, and the res- residential, and you wouldn't market to old people and young people exactly the same. Or, like, if they had- Yeah kids who are… Or if they were, um, you know, maybe they're, I don't know, mid-40s, 50s and they have, you know, younger kids-
40:53 Alex Sofronas: Mm-hmm um, but not babies, you know? So they care about a different set of channels. Uh- That's
40:58 Ryan Page: really interesting.
40:59 Alex Sofronas: Yeah.
41:00 Ryan Page: I, I like, I… So you'd buy a list and then cluster it, and then test against the different clusters.
41:08 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Yeah. Wow. See where your cost efficiencies are, right? That's interesting. So put, divide your… If you don't know which one's gonna do better, which in the beginning you won't- Yeah you just divide it equally- Yeah a- around the groups. So don't, like, over-leverage. Like, it's like- Yeah like, what is it? Uh- Roulette. It's like roulette, right? Uh-huh. Like, in the f- for the first round- Yeah like, that you- you're doing this. Like, just put your chips in, like, all the different things, or put it,
41:37 Alex Sofronas: like, a, like, on, on black or red- Mm and just see what happens. That- Yeah the black and- black or red. Th- this is not a good example. I-
41:46 Ryan Page: Yeah um, I'm usually- I- done with better examples. but the point is just hedge your bets for the first round. Yeah.
41:52 Alex Sofronas: Just where it takes you.
41:53 Ryan Page: Interesting.
41:54 Alex Sofronas: And then- And then experiment so would you then test with, Let's say your ICP is… I'll just give you mine 'cause it's the only one I- I- Let's see it it's the one I think about the most. So, it's, the high level is creative agency owner. I call her Social Media Sally. So- Nice I would… But I haven't thought of is some of what you're talking about, of, like, kids, no kids, creative agency versus full service agency kind of thing. So there's all these
42:25 Alex Sofronas: different variations. married, not married, yada, yada. Yeah.
42:29 Ryan Page: Which is interesting. So you go buy data around, like, that type of person, and then just run. She's on Instagram primarily from what I can tell.
42:39 Alex Sofronas: Uh- I
42:39 Ryan Page: wouldn't
42:40 Alex Sofronas: buy Instagram ads. You know what I'd do?
42:41 Ryan Page: Uh-huh.
Reaching your ICP through creators
42:42 Alex Sofronas: Have a, have your bot go out and message every creator that fits that persona-
42:53 Ryan Page: Yeah
42:54 Alex Sofronas: or that that type of person would probably follow.
42:57 Ryan Page: Huh.
42:57 Alex Sofronas: And you could even have, like, your AI analyze it. Like, look at this, like, here's some examples. Like, here's, like, five people that are- fit exactly in my, like, uh, you know, ICP.
43:11 Ryan Page: Yeah.
43:12 Alex Sofronas: look at who they're following. Try to break down who the influencers are of this type of person. Mm. Like, who, who's- who are the hottest influencers- Yeah for this type of person?
43:25 Ryan Page: Yeah. It
43:26 Alex Sofronas: might not have anything to do with agencies.
43:29 Ryan Page: Yeah.
43:30 Alex Sofronas: And that's fine And they, it does- they don't have to. Like, it- the point is to get their attention.
43:37 Ryan Page: Like- I always wonder that too, yeah. Yeah.
43:38 Alex Sofronas: That's
43:39 Ryan Page: interesting.
43:40 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, I mean, like, it's Look at pharma companies, they don't care. That's what I mean.
43:46 Ryan Page: That's
43:46 Alex Sofronas: a whole different beast. They'll, they'll sign a, a shot in the middle of a, like a comedy show or, or- or a very sad movie. They don't care. It's just about getting in front of you.
43:55 Ryan Page: Yeah. That's funny. Good one. There you go. That made up for your last one. Oh,
44:00 Alex Sofronas: yeah. Cool. Yeah. yeah, so the, they, It's about eyeballs and attention and-
44:08 Ryan Page: Yeah there's actually oftentimes, like I, I know, Epsilon data has this, but that's, that's at the enterprise level. I, I- Uh- I don't know if that is like a f- a thing that, like, you or I would get personally. Yeah.
44:24 Alex Sofronas: I would guess probably not. Uh. It's, it's an enterprise tool. Yeah. But I'm sure there's Like, you know what? Watt Data probably has something around it. Yeah. It's, it's- Uh they, they actually have data on how you spend your time. So, like, for each cluster, you can analyze, like, what are the general trends. Like, are they spending more time on this channel versus that channel? Yeah. And that becomes how y- and, and even for direct mail, they have direct mail responsiveness scores,
44:55 Alex Sofronas: and you can see if your audience is more responsive to direct mail, which is basically- Mm-hmm just looking at the average age. Um-
45:02 Ryan Page: Yeah 2: cause that's, the young people are not using it, so it's gonna naturally skew a little bit older. Sure.
45:09 Alex Sofronas: there's obviously many signals, but that- Yeah that's one of them. And, uh, and then, you know what my favorite thing that I my favorite creative optimization that I learned, 'cause I thought it was adorable, was that the creative that DirecTV used, for older folks-
45:27 Ryan Page: Yeah had bolder font It was like a little bolder, it was a little bit bigger. It was easier- Yeah right? A- and you think like, of course, right? Uh-huh. But I would not think that. I would definitely, like- Yeah like, that is a level of maturity, in the creative process. Totally.
45:46 Alex Sofronas: It's subtle. It's, like, very subtle.
45:49 Ryan Page: Yeah.
45:49 Alex Sofronas: I'm not- Um, like if you saw it and you didn't see the one that went to other people, you
45:52 Ryan Page: know.
45:52 Alex Sofronas: wouldn't
45:52 Ryan Page: Yeah. Yeah. That's always cool when they can get to that level, I mean.
45:57 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Yeah, I mean- you're talking world-class at that point.
46:00 Ryan Page: Y- yeah. It's like s- smallest shifts and probably so many variations the of things, so that's cool though. Hmm.
Champion vs. challenger testing
46:09 Alex Sofronas: So that's called the champion, and that's, that's what you would get to no matter what you're doing. Like, no matter what channel you choose-
46:17 Ryan Page: Yeah 2: the first thing you should do, and a lot of people make this mistake and they don't do, by not doing it- Hmm is establish a champion versus challenger mentality. What that means is, like, you, you need for this audience to have one evergreen creative. That means it's not based on, you know, oh, it's, it's June, that means it's this, you know, tent pole. You need to… You
46:47 Ryan Page: know, it's like, no, it, it needs to be general. Like, you can run it any time of year for this audience- Hmm and they'll respond. Like the, you remember, like… You, you, you would know this. Like, all those, like, really memorable ads, like any of 'em, are that. They're like champion ads. Like, they, doesn't, it's not like- Hmm
47:09 Alex Sofronas: "Come in this Friday." It's like, You remember that, what's that shaving brand, uh, that had that, like, massive Super Bowl commercial? It, it was just, like, them in, in the factory. I forget what it's called. But anyway-
47:23 Ryan Page: Mm it- talking about your brand, talking about what it means, what value it provides- Yeah
47:28 Alex Sofronas: and what you do with the champion and challenger is that you, you have this, you know, creative, and then you make one tweak to the creative. That's it.
47:38 Ryan Page: Mm.
47:39 Alex Sofronas: One thing. And you test it on a large enough group. So you, you would tell in, you know, in Claude, like, make sure- know, Yeah you what, what is my, minimum volume for the, uh, alternate version- Yeah so that we, we have statistical significance. Like, you should, you should do that. you know, if you're, if you're just Like, if it's underpowered, like if- Yeah if you're working with very large budgets, like, you're gonna be fine. You're- That's right but
48:09 Alex Sofronas: if you're, but if, if you're just starting out, like, this matters a lot. So start with, like, a 50/50 split if you're doubting it. Um-
48:18 Ryan Page: So the champion, the champion is the evergreen asset, and then the challenger is just, like, a small variation of the champion?
48:27 Alex Sofronas: One change. Okay. And then whoever wins, literally one change. Like-
48:31 Ryan Page: Yeah like, like, the background is more saturated. Yeah.
48:37 Alex Sofronas: And you see who wins. And then- And then- that person- You just keep iterating on it becomes the champion.
48:42 Ryan Page: Yeah.
48:42 Alex Sofronas: And then you challenge a different part.
48:45 Ryan Page: King of the Hill.
48:47 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. And you just- Huh keep doing it, and it just keeps getting more efficient because the audience- Yeah doesn't get tired of it, because the audience recycles.
48:57 Ryan Page: Yeah.
48:57 Alex Sofronas: New, new people enter the audience and, and exit it- Mm like, constantly. You know? It's like- Yeah it's not static. Yeah. That's the thing about behavior. You are learning- Mm how to, like, influence a particular audience's habits more- Yeah effectively with, like, the tiniest change. Isn't that fascinating?
49:20 Ryan Page: It's, yeah, it's cool. It's a, it's amazing honestly. I think, One of my first thoughts, though, is going to, all right, well now we just need a champion asset. Like, we need that big thing that, that works all the time, and I guess that comes back to- Nope what we were saying, like product market fit in a way, or no?
49:38 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, no, it's, it's easy though.
AI-made ads and Meta's AI creative
49:40 Ryan Page: Yeah.
49:40 Alex Sofronas: Now with AI, you- It's easy make 100.
49:44 Ryan Page: Spoken like an analyst.
49:46 Alex Sofronas: No, like, no, like li- literally you can just, you can have an AI make you a ton of different versions of something and say like, "This is my ICP."
49:57 Ryan Page: Where do you
49:57 Alex Sofronas: make
49:57 Ryan Page: AI ads? They still suck.
50:00 Alex Sofronas: Canva. Yeah, they do. Yeah, they do.
50:03 Ryan Page: Huh.
50:04 Alex Sofronas: You can go to, you can go to Fiverr and you'll at least get somebody who's accountable Yeah for them to not suck. But yeah, they do.
50:12 Ryan Page: I-
50:12 Alex Sofronas: at least they can do text now, kinda.
50:15 Ryan Page: Kinda.
50:16 Alex Sofronas: Before they were like-
50:18 Ryan Page: Yeah. just like, "We don't know words." Yeah. It's, You were talking about the Meta ads earlier when I asked you if you run them. Like they-- I just uploaded one, that I'm testing and it like, it suggests you upload it, you use AI to create an image of the ad too, and it like, their image thing is so bad. It like makes your face all splotchy and like removes words. It's like, what is this?
50:44 Alex Sofronas: Can I tell you the craziest thing? I did not believe it at first, and then over time I was like, "I guess." It's, it kinda like made me a little bit sad.
50:52 Ryan Page: Yeah. It worked?
50:54 Alex Sofronas: That stuff, that bad ad that sucks-
50:59 Ryan Page: Yeah 2: might work better, and- I- Meta has a vision model- Yeah Speaker 2: that it, they're able to produce ads. Yeah, 'cause that's the thing about machine learning is- Mm-hmm it understands patterns that we cannot comprehend, or at least we don't have the data to understand it, and we don't think- Yeah in the same way. Mm-hmm.
51:24 Alex Sofronas: And so it like, it unders- it like, it draws con- the weirdest connections and- It has the ability to personalize to, like, an audience of, I think, like, one, like at the individual level, but, but let's say like of five people. Yeah. Like it's, it, it's ultra targeted-
51:45 Ryan Page: Huh 2: and it's just testing on millions of people and millions of ads- Yeah every day, and it's learning from all of them. And the, and there's actual testimonials of people being like, "Yeah, that, that AI slop, it still converts because-" It's
52:02 Alex Sofronas: wild like the person might either under- like they might not even notice. Yeah. Like the, the Prince of Nigeria scams that, that like- Yeah they're looking for people who don't notice.
52:12 Ryan Page: to target. Huh. So I should turn it on?
52:15 Alex Sofronas: I say try it. It's
52:15 Ryan Page: like a half a face. It's like I'll
52:17 Alex Sofronas: scratch my
52:17 Ryan Page: face and-
52:17 Alex Sofronas: Throw out a message.
52:18 Ryan Page: See what happens yeah.
52:19 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Like see what happens. Yeah. S- see if you can beat your own, like y- We need a champion at least the volume and the personalization-
52:29 Ryan Page: Yeah
52:30 Alex Sofronas: that is compelling.
52:31 Ryan Page: Hmm.
52:32 Alex Sofronas: Like even if it's bad, you can't do that yourself.
52:37 Ryan Page: Yeah.
52:37 Alex Sofronas: Like that volume you can't do.
52:39 Ryan Page: Yeah. It's so- That's an aspect of it that I think is easy to forget. Like there's a, the perfectionist piece that's like, why would I put that out? Like that looks like crap. But yeah, you're right. Like at the end of the day, their model knows more than I think I know.
52:56 Alex Sofronas: Well, yes and no. You, you're also selling financial services, okay?
53:01 Ryan Page: Yeah.
53:02 Alex Sofronas: That is, that's a different thing than,
53:04 Ryan Page: Yeah an app- Yeah that's a game. Yeah.
53:08 Alex Sofronas: It's, it's not Candy Crush.
53:10 Ryan Page: True. so
53:11 Alex Sofronas: there, you know, that's a thing that- Yeah that's considered, you know, to give, to give credit where it's due. Yeah. It's, you know, there are- Yeah possible repercussions.
53:22 Ryan Page: Fair. You can caveat it. I was- It's okay.
53:25 Alex Sofronas: I was like-
53:26 Ryan Page: I'd still do it. It's
53:26 Alex Sofronas: fine.
53:27 Ryan Page: Yeah.
53:27 Alex Sofronas: Why not? Who's gonna know?
53:29 Ryan Page: Yeah.
53:29 Alex Sofronas: Who's gonna know? You would need to put millions of dollars into it for it to make a, like, an actual reputational impact- Yeah that people remember.
Marketing is all bets
53:37 Ryan Page: Yeah. Well, you've brought up roulette and now this, so I'm starting to think you like gambling.
53:43 Alex Sofronas: I don't. I don't. I would like to be the p- I watched The Gambler a few weeks ago.
53:48 Ryan Page: Yeah.
53:49 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, I, I think the way they ended that movie's probably caused a lot of gambling addiction, you know? It was-
53:54 Ryan Page: I-
53:55 Alex Sofronas: It was, like, a, a good ending. Huh. I was like, "Wow."
54:00 Ryan Page: Wow. It's hope- That's funny. It's hope.
54:03 Alex Sofronas: but no. No. it's, But it is, there is a lot of gambling in marketing in the sense that you have It's all bets.
54:11 Ryan Page: Yeah.
54:11 Alex Sofronas: It is. You know? That's, it's all testing, and-
54:13 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm when I was in a media buyer seat- Yeah I did the craziest testing, like, lots and lots of overlapping tests. So we did little things- I'm sure that's fun 'cause it's all other people's money too. You It's know? like, let me test all this all the time and-
54:31 Alex Sofronas: Well, yeah, but you s- you're still accountable. Like, it's, it's- Well,
54:34 Ryan Page: totally.
54:35 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, like,
54:35 Ryan Page: it's- I don't mean it in that fully, but yeah, there's, like, a different level of- Exactly.
54:39 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. No, y- yeah, you get to be, like-
54:45 Ryan Page: Yeah unrestrained. Yeah.
54:46 Alex Sofronas: With, with, in terms of, like-
54:48 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm what is possible. Like, if, especially if you have any data you want. Yeah.
Matching creative to the channel
54:54 Alex Sofronas: And, like, you Th- in the direct mail space, it's a completely different world than-
55:00 Ryan Page: Yeah the rest of the tactics. Like, if you're thinking about a video ad for TikTok- Yeah
55:08 Alex Sofronas: and you wanna put that on X or Facebook or whatever, it's fine. It'll probably work. if you have, like, a postcard that works really well, and you take, like, a picture of it, and you put it on any online tactic- Yeah probably not gonna work as well, right?
55:25 Ryan Page: Huh.
55:25 Alex Sofronas: It's, uh, probably gonna do terribly. Like, wh- it doesn't make it even make any sense. But, like-
55:30 Ryan Page: Yeah the point is also that different people react to those types of media. Hmm. So y- you know, or, like, TV- is the sibling of, you know, direct mail probably, I would say. Yeah.
55:43 Alex Sofronas: Um, they're probably gonna have pretty similar audiences. And I would say linear TV. That, and that's different than connected TV.
55:52 Ryan Page: Hmm.
55:53 Alex Sofronas: Um, prob- this is probably a huge overload, but yeah. Yes, like linear TV is like ca- cable, right? Connected TV is YouTube TV.
56:00 Ryan Page: Hmm.
56:01 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. So it's, it's gonna be different audiences and-
56:04 Ryan Page: Yeah you would want different creatives. So yeah, to the degree that you can, you wanna personalize. don't let a marketing comp- uh, don't let a marketing agency gouge you. Yeah.
56:14 Alex Sofronas: 'cause they do. That's like the number one thing I hear from people. It's like my-
56:20 Ryan Page: Yeah my marketing agency is charging me an arm and a leg. Yeah. It's, it's interesting being on the side of it where I work with marketing agencies and so it's like I see it, but then I also see the numbers side of it too. But it, yeah, the… I'd say noto- like, notoriously though, yes, I have been gouged by a few as well
56:40 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, I think we all have, right?
56:42 Ryan Page: Yeah. Yeah.
56:43 Alex Sofronas: Even myself, like, in the past.
56:46 Ryan Page: Yeah.
Agency benchmarks: the 50/30 rule
56:47 Alex Sofronas: I guess fin- final question, because this has turned into a hangout- is, is w- how is the marketing agency, and since you mentioned it, like, how is the profitability of that kind of a business? What are the things that separate the successful from the unsuccessful agencies from a financial perspective?
57:08 Ryan Page: gross margin is my favorite. Delivery margin it's called for agencies, 50%. 50 to 60% is the target, uh, gross profit margin per client, and then ultimately wrapping up to on the P&L total. And then, like, 20 to 30% profit margin, net profit margin, is kind of what is defined as, like, a, a perfectly healthy agency. The reality is, uh, what I see in
57:40 Ryan Page: a lot of them, is they're operating at, like, 30 to 40% gross margin, and then when you get down to the bottom line, it's like 10% or less, uh, a lot of the time. so yeah, I think the, the key metrics there are 50/30.
Volume, margin and concentration risk
57:57 Alex Sofronas: Okay. W- one… Wait. One quick question.
58:00 Ryan Page: Yeah.
58:01 Alex Sofronas: How do you account for volume?
58:03 Ryan Page: How do you account for volume?
58:04 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, like-
58:05 Ryan Page: Like- you, you could have, like, a 90% profit margin, but that's, maybe you cut out everybody besides your one most profitable customer, and then all of a sudden you have like- Well, then you have- one customer concentration risk, right?
58:19 Alex Sofronas: Right.
58:20 Ryan Page: So that's a different balance. I'd say most agencies are also battling concentration risk, too, where they have one big client, they're mostly over-servicing them, and then they have a bunch of smaller ones.
58:34 Alex Sofronas: Okay, so, so it's really, like, it's gross margin, gross profit, but also balanced against volume because those, those are, like, inversely related. Like, if you want to grow a lot, you're probably gonna have to widen your acceptance criteria, right? Like, you, you might have to bend a little bit. Yeah. Like, you know, that's gonna eat into your profit margin every time you do any favor.
59:01 Ryan Page: Yeah. It's, I mean, very clear scope, which is hard to do, but yeah, clear scope and then, I mean, yeah, you, you could, I guess, in theory, build a business off of, like, one, volume of one, but it's not very stable.
59:17 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, and, and that's maybe a bad example, but, like, there's, you know, serious decisions that companies have to make about, like, do we go for 1,000 clients or 50,000 clients?
59:32 Ryan Page: Totally. I think, I mean, they're usually high retainer projects, right? Like, I'd say five to- 30, 40, 50K per month retainers. Like, so there's a, a wide portfolio of, of clients usually in the mix there.
59:51 Alex Sofronas: Okay. Now you got, you got me thinking. This… You shouldn't have asked me.
Top-heavy agency teams
59:55 Ryan Page: Ah.
59:56 Alex Sofronas: what is the most successful structure of a marketing agency from what you've seen, like, for interest financial success?
60:05 Ryan Page: Structure from what standpoint? if you- Like financial statements or,
60:09 Alex Sofronas: uh, like the service- No, from a business, business ops perspective. What do they offer? how many clients do they take on? Like-
60:16 Ryan Page: do they productize it so it's self-serve, or do they keep it all behind a curtain and make it services? I think it depends, is the honest answer. I think if you, if you… What depends on the owner and what type of agency they want. Like, they can have a customized offering, but it's gonna get you only so far, where they're probably gonna have to productize over time if they want to grow it to something way bigger.
60:47 Alex Sofronas: Um- What about self-serve?
60:49 Ryan Page: Self-serve agency?
60:51 Alex Sofronas: No, like something the agency offered, um, as a service that they then productize and offer to the client self-serve in a portal or a tool or something.
61:02 Ryan Page: I've not seen anything like that.
61:04 Alex Sofronas: I guess like Google kind of- Yeah because they would have like people that get on calls and try to make you use P Max. And then they like released more analytics tools or something. Like, I- Yeah that's the think of it.
61:18 Ryan Page: I'm not seeing that from the agency standpoint, I would say.
61:21 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. So what do you… what is the different clusters that you see of like composition?
61:28 Ryan Page: I don't have a good answer for that, honestly, of like what is the ideal team size or what is the ideal… I think there's just so many variables that it's like hard to say XY- this service is what work- is what it works or this, t- yeah, like you said, team size or… I think at the end of the day, like if you have the, we have the metrics that we sort of align around, and then you try to like just balance things around it. Like I see a lot of agencies that are top-heavy, they want
61:59 Ryan Page: head of everything, and they have a head of everything, and then there's nothing for the owner. So I see that a lot.
62:05 Alex Sofronas: What do you mean by that, there's nothing for the
62:06 Ryan Page: owner? Like, like they're, they're just paying their team so much money, then there's no profit left.
62:13 Alex Sofronas: Oh.
62:14 Ryan Page: Yeah.
62:15 Alex Sofronas: And is that an investment? Does that pay off? Because then they get a lot of clients and a lot of good reputation, and then that grows naturally. They don't have to- No keep adding experts. It's like an upfront cost.
62:27 Ryan Page: Yeah. Not usually, I think.
62:30 Alex Sofronas: Oh, okay.
62:30 Ryan Page: I think it's just too… They invest too fast in people and too high level of people-
62:39 Alex Sofronas: Okay. So the altern- does the alternative work better? And h- how does that look?
62:45 Ryan Page: Yeah, I mean, it's interesting, right? 'Cause you want… Like, if I think of any founder, they wanna hire good people and let them build their team. a- and like that's, I think, like one of the best ways to grow a business. But I think with a lot of agencies it's like you think… I, I'm working with a full service agency right now. They're, they do SEO, they do p- PPC, Facebook ads, creative ads,
63:15 Ryan Page: websites. So they have a leader over each of those. They're paying each leader, let's say, 10 grand a month, so 50 grand a month in just, like, leaders, and then they have the team under. And so it's just like, is so… The, the team being like one or two small junior people, so it's like f- 10 grand a month to like 12- 1,200 a month. And it's just like there's no middle layer to where, like, they could accomplish more by not having this super
63:45 Ryan Page: high cost per hour person that's touching all these projects. Uh-
63:50 Alex Sofronas: Mm-hmm so they need, like, basically a, just a step up a little bit more to, to ease into the, like, labor burden and the load. Hmm. Is that where
Outsourcing and offshore leaders
64:02 Alex Sofronas: you see… Like, do consultancies fill that gap? Like a third-party fulfillment almost? I know, 'cause I know- Yeah there's like subcontractors for-
64:15 Ryan Page: Yeah agencies. Some people do that, like run through third-party fulfillment. I mean, that would definitely, like, simplify it, I think. I've honestly never worked with an agency who does all third-party fulfillment, so I assume there's like some wrap about it, but there's obviously huge companies that do it. But yeah, I've never, I've never seen it. Something I don't know why I didn't think of, 'cause, like, outsourcing is all over the place in accounting world, but uh, just, like,
64:47 Ryan Page: last week thought of that more f- with an agency of, like, hiring overseas talent for those leaders to then just, like, cut the, cut the weight, the, the wage in half and still have, like, leaders. But-
65:02 Alex Sofronas: And is that successful usually from what you've seen?
65:06 Ryan Page: I've not really done that either, honestly. I mean, I guess if I think about it, I have- I have one overseas guy that's paid US wages, so no. So yeah, I don't know. I mean, it's gotta work, right? They're, they're just as good overseas as they are here.
65:23 Alex Sofronas: Maybe, but part of the reason for that executive is the selling ability, which largely depends on understanding the customer- Yeah and the prospects. Yeah. Like, that's the point. So I could see, I could see, like, more functional, roles outsourcing makes a lot of sense.
65:44 Ryan Page: Yeah, not selling.
65:45 Alex Sofronas: High- yeah, high level-
65:47 Ryan Page: No like, impact-type- Mm-hmm roles don't seem like the ones to outsource. Yeah. But those are the top-heavy ones Yeah.
65:55 Alex Sofronas: It's tough, I get… No, I, I think, you know what's funny is, it, you're, you're right because of course you're right. Like, of course fake it till you make it is better than over-invest and do it by the book.
66:11 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm. Cause this is, it's ironic and it's fun, and that's like how a lot of things are, you know? Like, you jump in, and like those are the types that make it. Yeah.
66:24 Alex Sofronas: versus the ones that do everything like rigidly. And maybe some, maybe some do, but-
66:31 Ryan Page: Mm-hmm maybe something about the energy of the type of company that would just jump in- Yeah that also has something to do with it. Yeah. Yep.
Wrap-up
66:41 Alex Sofronas: Cool. All right, well, this has been a fun episode, way longer than the average, and not e- not expected. I did not- I did not expect this to go on, but I loved it, so thank you.
66:52 Ryan Page: Yeah, thank you too. It was fun.
66:54 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Cool. Well, uh, you know, you know what I'll offer is do some of the stuff we talked about and come back on in a couple of months-
67:04 Ryan Page: Yeah and we'll review your marketing. Okay. And I'll give you, like we'll talk about it on the podcast- Yeah what you can do differently, what you can test and- Yeah
67:13 Alex Sofronas: I, you know, whatever you wanna talk about.
67:15 Ryan Page: All right. That'd be cool. Sound
67:16 Alex Sofronas: good?
67:17 Ryan Page: Yeah. I'll send out some, some breakup kits and we'll see what happens.
67:21 Alex Sofronas: Yeah.
67:22 Ryan Page: Cluster models.
67:23 Alex Sofronas: I'm gonna send- That's- you my address. Yeah. Send a, send a bottle of whiskey, dear. Ooh- LTV's a big one. Look at LTV. LTV.
67:30 Ryan Page: Oh,
67:30 Alex Sofronas: yeah. Yeah, like, yeah. Look at-
67:33 Ryan Page: I don't… Where do you draw the li- I'll ask you this another time.
67:37 Alex Sofronas: No, yeah, yeah. Yeah. You, I'll, yeah, we'll, we'll talk.
67:41 Ryan Page: Yeah.
67:42 Alex Sofronas: Cool. Well, thank you, and, and thank you everyone for listening. We'll talk to you soon.