Raising $2.83M on Less Than $100K in Ads, with Jason Fishman | Transcript
Marketing x Analytics · Season 5, Episode 6 · November 17, 2026
Alex Sofronas talks with Jason Fishman, co-founder and CEO of Digital Niche Agency, about measuring ads against closed investments.
Listen on Apple Podcasts · Download the original captions (SRT)
This transcript uses the show’s published captions. Select a timestamp to jump to that point in the video.
Chapters
- 00:00 Cold open
- 00:18 Welcome
- 01:26 From mobile ads to investor acquisition
- 04:19 Turning investor data into an edge
- 07:35 How a small account becomes a big one
- 12:24 Agency politics
- 16:09 Rejection and reputation
- 19:26 Owning a mistake
- 20:58 Attribution and closed investments
- 25:41 Offers, perks, and share price
- 28:13 The empty restaurant problem
Cold open
00:00 Jason Fishman: First campaign under- under a hundred K in spend, including service fees, raised $2.83 million You have to be able to show a line around the block versus have the empty restaurant sensation.
Welcome
00:18 Alex Sofronas: Hello, and welcome to the Marketing x Analytics Podcast. I'm your host, Alex Sofronas, and today we're on with Jason Fishman. Jason, would you like to introduce yourself?
00:28 Jason Fishman: Absolutely. Thanks for having me on. Alex, I run an investor and user acquisition marketing agency here out of Marina del Rey, California. Been working on growth marketing campaigns for over fifteen years now, all different verticals, was running a mobile ad network with top one thousand type advertisers, focus in the growth stage space these days. Very exciting to be a part of, watch our clients, companies, market share, products evolve over time.
00:58 Jason Fishman: and could speak in depth about our traffic algorithms going after premium audiences, average order values, acquisition costs, all the stuff our clients want to dive into, as well as the content funnels and everything we do to see higher conversion rates. I showcase a lot of these findings on my podcast, Test. Optimize. Scale., over two hundred forty five episodes there. I do a monthly educational piece as well and serve on a variety of different marketing and capital raising professional associations.
From mobile ads to investor acquisition
01:26 Alex Sofronas: Wow. That's a pretty stacked resume. So how did you get into all of it? What was the origin story there?
01:34 Jason Fishman: Yeah. Yeah. Well, coming from mobile advertising, started an agency to be able to work full stack on these marketing campaigns and really focus on some of the groups in the Los Angeles startup community here and different verticals I was very active in. I found our niche in capital raising, investor and user acquisition, so going with groups to their growth milestones after a successful capital raise, because I found fundraising to be a common
02:03 Jason Fishman: theme. a common topic among our clientele. We were being asked to work on the marketing section of business plans as to how an organization was going to grow, put together pitch decks, reports for finance partners so they could scale the ad campaigns we were running once successful, even participating in these presentations to investors. And I learned about a set of laws, exemptions, starting with Reg D, which just allows for solicitation of accredited investors.
02:31 Jason Fishman: You can market to high net worth, high household income audiences. With my data partnerships, I was able to say, hey, I could target by income and net worth. I could target by portfolio size, by what people are doing online. First campaign, under a hundred K in spend, including service fees, raised two point eight three million dollars, got introduced to more companies, more issuers, more companies issuing investment opportunities, more platforms that were working as portals to marketplaces where these deals
03:01 Jason Fishman: are listed. The rules opened up further with regulation crowdfunding, investment crowdfunding. In twenty sixteen, we could raise up to five million dollars for most accredited or uncredited audiences, as well as regulation A plus. That's the last term I'll throw at you there. But you could raise up to seventy five million there. Public companies can even use it for price rounds. We've worked with companies who use the reg A to direct list and go public as well, too. So I found this specialization,
03:30 Jason Fishman: this niche, if you will, and it's a lot of fun to be part of. We're on the front lines of performance as marketers, but we'll raise millions of dollars. We've worked on over five hundred campaigns. Those campaigns have collectively produced hundreds of millions in capital. many of the top deals this year and past years. I built my own first party audience data at this point as well through data mining and different data partnerships. I have a list of over one point eight million historical regulation
03:58 Jason Fishman: crowdfund investors I could upload as a custom audience and advertise directly to. So because of the value we were driving for clients, continue to work further and further into this space.
04:11 Alex Sofronas: That's interesting. Are you a one-man band? How many people are on your team?
04:15 Jason Fishman: About fifteen employees. A little over five contractors outside of that.
Turning investor data into an edge
04:20 Alex Sofronas: and so you did the smart data gathering thing of, like, you know, monetizing... the data that you've kind of come across and been able to collect across your career i think that's that's a very smart move how just zooming into that piece um how do you monetize that like is that something that you offer to people like hey i can target uh this unique audience that you can't really you know that's uh
04:51 Alex Sofronas: i've crafted um Or like, or do you just use that mainly for yourself and for marketing to potential prospects?
04:59 Jason Fishman: It's a great question. I'm on a lot of these podcasts, and I have not been asked that before. The audience I refer to as our secret sauce. I was testing different lists that were sent over to me and starting to see stronger performance. I then worked collaboratively with those portals, those marketplaces, and had them share audiences over these ad platforms that I could advertise to. and saw a big lift in performance,
05:27 Jason Fishman: lower acquisition costs. I mean, we're talking under a hundred dollars for closed investment of let's say an average of a thousand, two thousand dollars on these retail campaigns and said, hey, I can't rely just on partnerships. I need to build my own. Monetization of that, we charge a monthly campaign quarterbacking fee, monthly agency service fee, retainer fee, plus a percentage of ad spend.
05:57 Jason Fishman: A lot of the ad spends start at lower amounts and then scale to much larger amounts. not uncommon for, let's say, media campaigns as a whole. But just to paint a picture, we've worked with fintech apps, cryptocurrency exchanges that start under ten K a month in ad spend, even all in that have later scaled over several month process to seven figure a month ad spend levels. Once the acquisition cost is there,
06:25 Jason Fishman: they're basically buying more investments, buying more assets under management, buying more of whatever they're measuring. So using that data as well as our in-house creative services, our percentage for ad management would be looked at as on the higher end. I don't think it is, especially for lower ad spends. And we find the right levels as clients are scaling. I've explored the use of data fees and even selling to other agencies and other
06:53 Jason Fishman: media buyers, data programs. I found if they're not buying the advertising the right way, they wouldn't be seeing as strong as performance as we would. And there's a coaching element to this. So I have really held to our agency services around it. I should be able to show more revenue around the data itself versus our service fees for M and a merchant acquisition type conversations and, uh,
07:22 Jason Fishman: exploring different, uh, you know, uh, entities around data and what can be built at the moment, but that's worked very well for us and we've received good response responses from clients around how we structure it.
How a small account becomes a big one
07:35 Alex Sofronas: Okay. Yeah, you mentioned growing smaller clients and this is the whole game in the services industry. It's growing small clients to big clients and then acquiring big clients, making them bigger, retaining them. Because then they're the hot girl, and they get to have their pick.
07:58 Jason Fishman: Then they RFP every year,
08:00 Alex Sofronas: and they name their terms. And then that's a whole different game than growing. So I want to know, elements of us of your services that you've identified like what it was what's the key to growing a small account to a larger account and how does that differ from keeping a larger account and winning
08:24 Jason Fishman: larger accounts it's all around performance metrics direct response companies in many cases I hate to say it, but one budget has to produce the next. So we're graded heavily on cost per acquisition, cost per purchase, return on ad spend, marketing efficiency ratio, how we speak about that, can firmly dictate whether we're able to
08:53 Jason Fishman: continue with the group or not. And it's mind boggling when I see other agencies fail there and look at performance and say, oh, you know, this was actually good. They should have encouraged you to keep that longer. And we're just playing at results and not trash talking any other agencies, medifiers, anything like that. We work alongside other groups in many scenarios. But it all really comes down to those results, whether it's a small client and we're able to say, hey, you're getting a three X return on advertising,
09:21 Jason Fishman: spending a ten X return on advertising spend. We want to increase your daily pacing from the monthly budget with your approval. Hey, that's worked. Now we are recommending that you scale. This is a smaller budget. We could double the ad spend here. different than a larger ad budget where maybe it's a ten twenty percent increase for that channel and then increasing within that channel adding additional channels seeing what's performing best
09:50 Jason Fishman: optimizing towards working best once we you know enhance what we're doing within each of those channels with each audience each creative each funnel that we're taking them down the large clients They appear to be more attractive, right? There's a saying that they're quick to hire, quick to fire in many cases, and even at very large budget levels. You're also going against their current marketing stack. So if you get in there and you're performing and there's not too much going
10:19 Jason Fishman: on on the political side internally or with other agencies, they will increase what you're doing. That politics piece of it, there could be other agencies stating why what they're doing is better, what you're doing is wrong, or fighting for whatever they think is right, contracts. There's things that could get in the way there, even if you're performing very well. You can get an email, we're not using outside partners for the next quarter. I mean, there's all different types of things that could get in the way outside of performance.
10:47 Jason Fishman: But typically, if the results are there, they'll increase it. They'll go off your recommendations. If it continues to perform as projected, they'll take it to higher levels. The monetization side could get a little tricky there as well too, because if you're charging a percentage of ad spend, any percentage of ad spend, and you're getting to much larger ad spend levels, it starts becoming more and more appealing to them and maybe their CFO. maybe they're accountants,
11:15 Jason Fishman: maybe they're consultants to take this in-house or find someone who will work at a flat rate. And you have to continue to communicate the value that you're bringing to the table and how the relationships you're having with media partners, with data partners, how the campaigns you're running outside of theirs are leading to learnings, findings that are able to provide value to them. So, so much of this is really an ongoing business development process.
11:44 Jason Fishman: our account managers, our campaign quarterbacks need to be able to speak this language. Otherwise, you could get cut off and very quickly, even with the right results. But that being said, the scales, the continuation with large clients, it's really all about the numbers in this world. We're not able to speak to the branding metrics and have the same effect, not able to speak to different advising and coaching, at least not to the same level, at least not for some of the numbers we would be able to get coming
12:14 Jason Fishman: in from percentage and sharing in the earnings. And it only happens because they're able to see all of that extra monetary value coming in.
12:23 Alex Sofronas: So they want to do more.
Agency politics
12:26 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. And when you are facing politics with another agency, and it's a mess, what do you focus on to break through the noise? Or is it more like you cut your losses and if it's too messy, you move on?
12:47 Jason Fishman: It's all style. So I'll share my approach. It's important to note this isn't black and white. It's not, hey, here's the only way to do it. I like to say that we play well with others. And we do. We work alongside other agencies, other in-house teams, very effectively. We are, I'll emphasize again, playing towards the results, those case studies. Beyond that, just the satisfaction and fulfillment that
13:16 Jason Fishman: a company is growing. So that is our goal. Again, there's other agencies that want to say they can only be the only group involved or for a certain specific channel. They're competitive. They want to do whatever they can to point out what's wrong, even without solutions to follow. I look to befriend the other agencies. I've had agencies on my podcasts. I'm on panels with them regularly. I was on panels with other groups last night. But one of them even worked with the same group of us as us.
13:48 Jason Fishman: For my vertical specifically of investor acquisition, investment crowdfunding, investor acquisition, LP, GP, limited partner, general partner acquisition towards funds, I look at it as a rising tide lifts all ships. So if we run a successful campaign, it's good for the other agencies. If agencies do, it's good for us. If we're working on it together, we just have to speak about it in a way that's good for everyone. I believe in teams. So I attempt to build that relationship. sometimes tell me something different than
14:18 Jason Fishman: they tell the agency sometimes it's beneficial sometimes it completely works against us and can weigh upon the dishonest side uh you know from some of these groups you can only control what you can control though i've found agencies that appreciate it they say you know we're on the phone with southern group they're always trying to say how what you're doing these are the publishers all these other groups are doing wrong and they're not performing You haven't said a bad thing about them. You've given us tips on how to work with them to see higher performance in those channels. That says a lot about you.
14:46 Jason Fishman: We appreciate that. So that's the school that I operate within. I'm a problem solver. I think good marketing talent requires that attribute. So I'm not of the mindset of, hey, I'm going to walk away. And we have a ton of other stuff. I don't need to worry about this. If I'm enrolled in a conversation, I want to see it through to a point of effectiveness.
15:10 Alex Sofronas: I like that. Yeah, it seems counterintuitive. The more competitive it is, the more that collaboration differentiates
15:20 Jason Fishman: you. I think so. I think the people who are very best at what they do in the world look at how they can be better, whether we're talking about a professional golfer, whether we're talking about a top data analyst, whatever it may be. those who are trying to say how they are better than others and they're the best at something, I find just as a general statement, are not and are maybe trying to overcompensate for something there.
15:50 Jason Fishman: I believe there's always better results available with marketing and marketing campaigns, even in the most outstanding levels of performance. I try to look at it that way. People I look up to and in different areas of expertise do as well.
16:06 Alex Sofronas: So that's been our approach towards this.
Rejection and reputation
16:11 Alex Sofronas: Right. And when you are playing at that level, there's inevitably going to be people who attack you.
16:18 Jason Fishman: Yeah.
16:20 Alex Sofronas: Do you brush it off? Because sometimes that's attacking your reputation, right?
16:30 Jason Fishman: so i've been part of the business development process uh and everything i've done since the beginning of my career as a good marketer i think you get pulled into those discussions you're able to be enrolling you're able to find ways to get people excited and business development you're kind of in a world of uh uh rejection you know if you have two out of ten prospects moving forward on scalable business development channels you're in a good place which means eight
17:00 Jason Fishman: out of ten are telling you no or disappearing or you know telling you yes and it just doesn't move forward or whatever it consists of when we're talking about digital marketing metrics i wrote an article one time marketing does not work The truth, because, you know, one percent click through rate, a one, two percent conversion rate are very good results. Meanwhile, for any other product, you look at that as something that does not work. So, you know, you have all these no's around you and
17:28 Jason Fishman: you need to be able to build relationships through that. I've seen strategic partners. I've seen longstanding clients of ours tell us no at first. And we maintain a good relationship, a good report, things I could have got mad at. Things I could have been very aggressive or retaliatory towards, but they would not have benefited me. They would not have benefited the client, the partner, anyone like that. And being a good person by being in group that we would want to work with, we've been able to shine through that.
17:57 Jason Fishman: I look at the same thing as when we're at Target. It's funny. I remember meeting some of my good friends and not liking them at first or them attacking at first and then building a friendship through that. There's these stories of boxers who hated each other and now they're best friends and have been for decades afterwards. I've been able to build relationships with those people who have attacked us and found value for both sides and mutually
18:25 Jason Fishman: beneficial relationship and agreement. I saw ego destroy some of the positions of companies I was at early on in my career before starting my own businesses and learned you have to really look at what's going to benefit you, what's not, and people are watching you. I try to brush it off. I try to look to build rapport, build a dialogue with people when that's occurring. That's worked for me.
18:54 Jason Fishman: It's not everyone's approach, I suppose. But, you know, be the bigger person. Find a way to partner. Find a way to do something. Show that it doesn't bother you. There are more prospects. Even that reputation aspect of it, I think at some point in everyone's career, at some point in every business's trajectory, there's going to be something that occurs that hurts their reputation. And it's how they respond in those moments that defines who they are, if it's an individual as their character, if it's for a company, it's their brand.
19:24 Jason Fishman: And you got to find a way to
19:25 Alex Sofronas: push through it.
Owning a mistake
19:28 Alex Sofronas: I like that a lot. It reminds me of the Apple is like the iPhone four and the signal was dropping when you held the phone that way. And then they gave everybody those free cases to fix it. And they just owned it and, you know, fixed it, you know, elegantly and, And there would have been plenty of, you know, companies don't usually do that. Like they owned it and they made it loud about what is the fix. You know, they absorbed it.
19:57 Alex Sofronas: And I think that did a lot of good for them. Obviously, they're doing quite well. So when's the last time, you know, I don't know, the Samsung did that, you know, about, you know, one of their phones that was buggy. You know, it's not common.
20:13 Jason Fishman: Mm-hmm. Apple gets attacked all day long as well, too. Samsung devices are better. They're more advanced. Tech people use Samsung. Apple's for general population and create anything new. They're still the top brand, if not in the conversation to be the top brand in the world. I'm an enthusiast. Many people I know are enthusiasts. They have enough people to hit their goals and be able to accelerate and It shows not everything needs to be
20:44 Jason Fishman: addressed as, hey, this completely destroys our reputation as much as, all right, what do we do from here? As a brand, as individuals, how do we address this? And a lot of times you can find yourself in a better spot thereafter. Yeah.
Attribution and closed investments
21:00 Alex Sofronas: I want to move back to your core business for a moment. And specifically, you're reaching a very unique group of people. I guess it's not B to B, but it's very much more targeted than B to C. Right. Because you're targeting, you know, you're basically targeting the sources of investor funds, right? Like individuals that can sort of corral investor funds,
21:29 Alex Sofronas: just to put it very bluntly or broadly. using to understand the responsiveness of that audience? Because, you know, I guess you mentioned direct response and that I guess I suppose would work if you have a sort of a lead funnel and you're getting them to respond to something, but I'm curious, like what, what does that attribution system look like?
21:52 Jason Fishman: There are different types of capital raises. So just to remove one of them from the conversation, regulation crowdfunding, Regulation A+, allow for retail investments. Average investment may be a couple grand, maybe five, six grand, but across thousands of investors. Worked on a deal, Rad Intel, that oversubscribed at sixty five million in June. They now have a Reg CF campaign live. They have over thirty thousand investors to date. So that is going through an offering page
22:22 Jason Fishman: where the transaction occurs directly on that page. To give other examples, Mode Mobile has over a hundred million raised across deals now, over seventeen million last month alone, well over seventy thousand investors. So it's not to say what I'm about to speak about next, and per the nature of your question, is better or bigger or anything like that but if we're speaking about regulation d accredited investors so you're talking high net worth individuals high household
22:50 Jason Fishman: income households And in some cases, the traffic still does run to an offering page that manages the transaction. And we'll see investments come through that don't involve an offline conversation. So it's tracked with an advertising pixel and everything takes place through that funnel. In most cases, it's lead generation, lead nurturing. So an advertisement, outreach messaging,
23:23 Jason Fishman: organic content leading to a landing page that has a form, form is completed, and there is some type of exchange thereafter, whether it's downloading a digital asset such as an investor deck, whether it's signing up for a the next webinar. Some groups use recorded webinars, evergreen, that people could always log into. More commonly, a live webinar.
23:51 Jason Fishman: In other scenarios, it's a call booking system, where someone reaches out to then schedule a call. And then it goes into the CRM, Customer Relationship Management Platform. And how that's plugged into the dashboard could then allow us to calculate how much of the traffic, how many leads, and from which traffic sources have moved into each stage of the closing process, from scheduling a call, attending a call.
24:20 Jason Fishman: There could be a variety of steps afterwards for receiving different information, filling out different contracts all the way through, but what we want to look at is closed investments. So that could be reported and the data could be going into a dashboard directly. It could be done manually where we're looking at the leads and then seeing how many of them are closing, looking at the source of the leads thereafter so we can shape our audience targeting and creative channels accordingly. But it needs to be a close communication system between the investor relations
24:49 Jason Fishman: team, which may include the CEO, it may include COO, a founder, maybe someone whose sole job is just to speak to perspective. investors but close communication system so we can gauge where the best quality leads are coming from as well as which leads have closed and the transactional value so we can get a better idea of the marketing efficiency ratio we've recently built funnels that include different tools for lead scoring as well and actually research the individual who
25:19 Jason Fishman: submitted the lead creates a dossier like a bio on the investors, so the investor relations team has more to speak to, talking about their assets, talking about schooling, job title, if available, investment portfolio, so that there's more to work off of and leads can be prioritized. They can even receive different funnel content to follow.
Offers, perks, and share price
25:42 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, and are you using offers at all? Is that a thing in your world? Because I know in the regular B to C world, you'll see offers all the time.
25:53 Jason Fishman: Offers, discounts, things along those lines.
25:57 Alex Sofronas: Yeah. Yeah.
25:58 Jason Fishman: I don't know, but I'm curious. Yeah. Every investor has to be presented with the same information and same terms. That is why these exemptions were created, to democratize both access to capital for issuers and going beyond their first-degree networks, listening to investors, as well as access to investment opportunities and deal flow to the investors. can you provide discounted share price?
26:29 Jason Fishman: And by the way, some of these are common stock, preferred stock, some are debt deals, different types of fixed interest returns, different types of safes, convertible notes, revenue shares, different ways to structure it. But you can put into the filing for Reg CF, for Regulation A+, uh different uh perks so if you put a thousand dollars or more five thousand twenty five thousand a hundred thousand
26:59 Jason Fishman: you get this added value in shares that there's things that uh could be done uh discounts and could be an offer i spoke at a an entertainment film festival yesterday on a finance panel and there's perks of getting your name in the credits having lunch with the director being in the actual movie as an extra there's different perks at different levels that are uh you know allowed for but everyone's operating at the same valuation uh same
27:29 Jason Fishman: share price same offers just they could come in accordingly but they're offered to come in at those different levels uh The Regulation A-plus campaigns often feature a share price increase, which allows for an immediacy, a closing event, a fear of missing out. So September tenth, share price going from eighty-five cents to ninety-one cents. then over the course of six months or a year, you're able to show how the share price
27:58 Jason Fishman: has increased and for a private company in most cases. So there's a whole strategy around that as well too. But you can set different sweeteners of the deal, if you will. They just have to be available to everybody. Got it.
The empty restaurant problem
28:13 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, that's really interesting. And yeah, no, I really appreciate learning. This is such a new area that I haven't thought about before. I guess final thoughts, anything else you'd like to share about your business or anything with the listeners that you think they would benefit from?
28:31 Jason Fishman: I've learned so much from these crowd sales that applies to marketing of every vertical. Learned about reward crowdfunding on Kickstarter and Indiegogo, which are thirty-day sprints and they were the result of a good pre-launch and hitting a third of your external goal at a minimum on that first day. And I apply that towards other marketing campaigns. We'll work with the company on a regulation crowdfund and then work towards their ticket sales or their e-commerce sales or their user acquisition or their B
29:00 Jason Fishman: to B marketing thereafter. But it's all based on social dynamics. I know my purchases, my travel, where I go to restaurants, it's based on social dynamics. I've heard about a place, I've strongly recommended to do something. I was advised I keep hearing about these types of workout programs. And that shapes my day-to-day choices. Investment crowdfunding, if you're going to run one of these
29:29 Jason Fishman: campaigns, you bring an existing crowd. First-degree network, friends, family, email list, social audience. You show there's a hundred thousand raised from fifty investors on an average of two thousand dollars each or a million dollars raised. From a lead investor, you have to be able to show a line around the block versus have the empty restaurant sensation. So what you're doing with press and establishing third party validation and
29:57 Jason Fishman: social proof shows up in the conversion rate. And you really need to show that there's already a strong demand desire for what you're doing, which could be difficult in the early stages of an investment round. But I've taken this to other types of marketing campaigns and it's changed the way I've looked at marketing. It's changed the timelines. So I would say whatever you're looking to get conversions from today, you can take some of these same
30:27 Alex Sofronas: Yeah, I love that. I really appreciate you sharing, Jason. And, you know, thanks again for joining.
30:34 Jason Fishman: And yeah, well, thanks, everyone,
30:37 Alex Sofronas: for listening. We'll talk to you soon.